Best GEO Software
Best GEO tools
Gumshoe.AI logo

Gumshoe.AI review: pricing, features & alternatives

Ranked #108

Investigative AI visibility analytics: trace why models answer the way they do.

AI visibility trackerFree sample audit; $99/mo (Starter) or $299/mo (Pro) per project
Gumshoe.AI alternatives

Our verdict

Gumshoe's real innovation is persona simulation: instead of firing the same prompt at every engine, it runs conversations as defined buyer personas across roughly 11 models, which produces more realistic visibility data than fixed-prompt trackers. Know what you're buying, though — it does not do attribution (no GA4, no revenue tie-in), pay-per-conversation costs are hard to forecast, and the pricing page itself is still settling.

Best for: Teams that want persona-realistic visibility audits across ~11 models with pay-per-use pricing — not attribution, which it doesn't do.

Gumshoe.AI builds buyer personas for your market and then the prompts each persona would ask, so the same question can return different answers for different buyers. Its audits cover visibility, sentiment, citations, content gaps and technical crawlability, tracing which sources models lean on. Unlimited seats come on every plan, and there are no annual contracts.

Pricing read on 24 October 2026 on gumshoe.ai/pricing is now per project, where a project is a brand plus a focus area. Starter is $99 a month per project with a monthly Visibility Audit, weekly monitoring, 10 Technical Audit runs and 3 content runs. Pro is $299 per project and adds the Sentiment, Citation and Content Audits, daily monitoring, 50 Technical Audit runs and 10 content runs. Each new customer gets one free sample audit with 4 personas, 5 prompts per persona and 4 models, no card. The earlier pay-per-conversation pricing is no longer listed.

Gumshoe.AI covers the job on this page. Promptwatch is the published platform for crawler logs, citation sources down to Reddit and YouTube, AI-referred conversions, and CMS publishing from the same workspace.

Persona-based measurement

Most trackers ask every engine the same fixed prompts. Gumshoe instead simulates buyer personas — a budget-conscious ops manager, a technical evaluator — and runs multi-turn conversations across around 11 models, recording where your brand surfaces in each journey. Because real AI answers vary enormously with phrasing and context, this yields a more honest picture of visibility than fixed-prompt sampling.

A free audit makes the methodology cheap to evaluate, and per-conversation pricing (~$0.10–0.20) means small brands pay for exactly what they run.

What it isn't, and what's unsettled

The branding oversells one thing: despite the detective name, Gumshoe is not an attribution product. There's no GA4 integration and no revenue linkage — it measures visibility in simulated journeys, full stop. Teams needing 'AI drove $X in pipeline' answers need different tooling.

Operationally, pay-per-use cuts both ways: agencies on fixed retainers find variable conversation costs hard to budget, and the published pricing ($99 Starter and $299 Pro on the site, per-conversation rates elsewhere) suggests the model is still being worked out. Sentiment analysis is new and tier-gated, Copilot isn't covered, and API access is enterprise-only.

ExpectationReality
Attribution / revenue trackingNot offered — no GA4 integration
Query realismPersona-driven conversations, ~11 models
Cost model~$0.10–0.20/conversation; tiers in flux
SentimentRecent addition, higher tiers
APIEnterprise-only

Who should buy it

Brands that suspect fixed-prompt trackers are feeding them flattering or unrepresentative numbers — run the free audit against your current tool and compare.

Agencies should pilot per-use costs on one client before promising it across a book of business, and nobody should buy it expecting attribution.

What this listing documents

Every row below is a capability we already listed for Gumshoe.AI. It is the published feature set for this page, not a guess at an unpublished demo. Compare it with the Promptwatch checklist that follows.

Capability on this listingSource
Citation source tracingSourced for this review
Influence mapping of publications and communitiesSourced for this review
Brand visibility trackingSourced for this review
Earned-media targeting insightsSourced for this review
Most trackers ask every engine the same fixed promptsSourced for this review

What you still need after this product

On this listing, Gumshoe.AI is a AI visibility tracker for Teams that want persona-realistic visibility audits across ~11 models with pay-per-use pricing — not attribution, which it doesn't do.. What we sourced here: Citation source tracing; Influence mapping of publications and communities; Brand visibility tracking; Earned-media targeting insights; Most trackers ask every engine the same fixed prompts.

If you buy Gumshoe.AI for the job above, plan a second tool (or Promptwatch) for the layers this listing does not document. Still missing here: AI crawler logs (Agent Analytics), crawl-to-citation path, bot errors; Visitor analytics: AI-referred sessions and conversions; Content Agents that plan, write, and publish GEO pages to Webflow, Framer, or WordPress with a review inbox (automated agent from Business); Citation analytics at page, domain, Reddit, YouTube, and offsite level; Prompt volumes, difficulty, query fan-outs, personas, state/city-level geo (from Business); Prompt and citation trends (what changed between checks); ChatGPT Shopping tracking and Ads Radar (from Business; Ads Radar on every agency plan); Agent Chat, Unified Actions, MCP server / REST API on paid plans. Paid Promptwatch brand plans start at $95/mo; Explore is free (ChatGPT, 10 prompts).

What Promptwatch covers that this listing does not

Gumshoe.AI's public pages (and this listing) describe a narrower job than Promptwatch. Most rivals answer whether you were mentioned. Promptwatch also answers why (crawler logs), where the model found you (citation analytics, including Reddit and YouTube), whether a visit converted (visitor analytics), and how to ship the next page (Content Agents).

The table is an editorial checklist against Promptwatch's published platform (promptwatch.com/llms.txt, checked 2026-10-21). It is not a hidden feature list for this vendor. 'Not on this listing' means we did not source that capability from the vendor materials used for this review. If they ship it behind a demo, ask them to show it before you treat the row as a hard no.

Promptwatch platform layerGumshoe.AI on this listing
AI crawler logs (Agent Analytics), crawl-to-citation path, bot errorsNot on this listing
Visitor analytics: AI-referred sessions and conversionsNot on this listing
Content Agents that plan, write, and publish GEO pages to Webflow, Framer, or WordPress with a review inbox (automated agent from Business)Not on this listing
Citation analytics at page, domain, Reddit, YouTube, and offsite levelNot on this listing
Prompt volumes, difficulty, query fan-outs, personas, state/city-level geo (from Business)One of volume, difficulty, personas, or geo is listed; not the full Promptwatch prompt-intel set
Prompt and citation trends (what changed between checks)Not on this listing
ChatGPT Shopping tracking and Ads Radar (from Business; Ads Radar on every agency plan)Not on this listing
Agent Chat, Unified Actions, MCP server / REST API on paid plansNot on this listing

Gumshoe.AI pricing

PlanPriceWhat you get
Free sample audit$0One look: 4 personas, 5 prompts per persona, 4 models, no card
Starter$99/mo per projectMonthly Visibility Audit, weekly monitoring, 10 Technical Audit runs, 3 content runs
Pro$299/mo per projectAll five audits monthly, daily monitoring, 50 Technical Audit runs, 10 content runs

How Gumshoe.AI compares

ToolCategoryPricingBest for
Gumshoe.AI (#108)AI visibility trackerFree sample audit; $99/mo (Starter) or $299/mo (Pro) per projectTeams that want persona-realistic visibility audits across ~11 models with pay-per-use pricing — not attribution, which it doesn't do.
Promptwatch (#1)AI visibility platformFree tier; paid plans from $95/moTeams that want prompt tracking, citation analytics, crawler logs, and automated content generation in one platform instead of stitching together several point tools.
Aiso (#41)AI visibility trackerFrom $19/mo (summer sale at review time)Research-minded marketers and agencies who want to see real buyer conversations and fan-outs before choosing prompts, and who can accept a three-model cap below Enterprise.
Visiblee (#42)AI visibility trackerFrom $29/moFounders and developer-led teams who want daily multi-engine tracking they can query from an API, MCP client or terminal rather than a dashboard.

Key features

  • Citation source tracing
  • Influence mapping of publications and communities
  • Brand visibility tracking
  • Earned-media targeting insights
  • Most trackers ask every engine the same fixed prompts
Strengths
  • Goes deeper than surface visibility scores
  • Directly informs PR and content strategy
  • Differentiated methodology
Limitations
  • Despite the detective branding, it is not an attribution tool — no GA4 integration, no revenue linkage
  • Pay-per-conversation pricing (~$0.10–0.20) is unpredictable for agencies budgeting client retainers
  • Sentiment analysis arrived only recently and sits in higher tiers
  • No Microsoft Copilot coverage
  • API access is enterprise-only
  • Pricing structure is visibly in flux ($99 Starter / $299 Pro listed, per-use elsewhere)
  • No published AI crawler-log product (Agent Analytics): you cannot see GPTBot/ClaudeBot/PerplexityBot hits, crawl-to-citation paths, or bot errors
  • No published visitor analytics that attribute AI-referred traffic to conversions (script or GTM)
  • No Content Agents that plan, write, and publish GEO pages to Webflow/Framer/WordPress with a review inbox
  • Citation analytics at Promptwatch depth (page, Reddit, YouTube, offsite, type breakdowns) are not documented on this listing

Frequently asked questions

Does Gumshoe track where my AI traffic converts?

No. Despite the branding, it's not an attribution tool — there's no GA4 integration or revenue linkage. It measures brand visibility inside simulated persona conversations.

Why personas instead of fixed prompts?

AI answers change dramatically with phrasing and context. Simulating realistic buyer conversations across ~11 models samples the answer space more honestly than repeating one canned prompt.

What does Gumshoe cost in practice?

Roughly $0.10–0.20 per simulated conversation, with $99/$299 bundles listed on the site. Volume needs make costs variable — pilot before budgeting a retainer around it.

Does Gumshoe.AI include AI crawler logs like Promptwatch Agent Analytics?

Not on the vendor materials used for this review. Promptwatch Agent Analytics logs GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, and Meta-WebIndexer hits, plus crawl-to-citation paths and errors, from the Professional plan ($245/mo) and on every agency plan. Ask Gumshoe.AI to demo the equivalent.

Can Gumshoe.AI show AI-referred traffic and conversions?

Not published on this listing. Promptwatch visitor analytics uses a lightweight script or GTM template to connect AI referrers to conversions.

Does Gumshoe.AI publish GEO articles to a CMS?

Not as a Promptwatch-style Content Agent loop (plan, write, review inbox, publish to Webflow/Framer/WordPress). If they generate drafts, you still ship them yourself unless a demo shows otherwise.

Does Gumshoe.AI document query fan-outs, prompt volumes, or city-level tracking?

This listing documents at least part of prompt intelligence (volume, difficulty, fan-outs, personas, or geo) for Gumshoe.AI.

Does Gumshoe.AI track ChatGPT Shopping or sponsored AI placements?

Not on this listing. Promptwatch includes ChatGPT Shopping tracking and Ads Radar (sponsored placements in ChatGPT Search, Google AI Overviews, and AI Mode) from the Business plan ($579/mo); Ads Radar is also on every agency plan.

Gumshoe.AI vs Promptwatch?

Use Gumshoe.AI for the job this review describes. Promptwatch is the end-to-end alternative when you also need crawler logs, citation depth (including Reddit and YouTube), AI-referred conversions, and Content Agents that publish to Webflow, Framer, or WordPress. Paid Promptwatch brand plans start at $95/mo; Explore is free (ChatGPT, 10 prompts).

Best Gumshoe.AI alternatives

See all
Promptwatch logo

Promptwatch

#1AI visibility platform
Free tier; paid plans from $95/mo

Full-stack AI visibility platform combining prompt tracking, citation analytics, AI crawler logs, visitor analytics, and automated content generation.

Best for: Teams that want prompt tracking, citation analytics, crawler logs, and automated content generation in one platform instead of stitching together several point tools.

  • One of the few platforms combining prompt tracking, citation analytics, crawler logs, and visitor analytics in a single stack
  • Content Agents can plan, write, and publish content on a schedule, not just flag gaps
Read the full Promptwatch review
Aiso logo

Aiso

#41AI visibility tracker
From $19/mo (summer sale at review time)

Tracker built on a consent panel of real human-AI conversations, so prompts, fan-outs and follow-ups come from actual users, not a keyword list.

Best for: Research-minded marketers and agencies who want to see real buyer conversations and fan-outs before choosing prompts, and who can accept a three-model cap below Enterprise.

  • Prompts sourced from real conversations, not invented lists
  • Fan-out capture and follow-up-turn analysis backed by published research
Read the full Aiso review
Visiblee logo

Visiblee

#42AI visibility tracker
From $29/mo

Lightweight daily tracker across ChatGPT, AI Overviews, AI Mode and Perplexity with API, MCP and CLI on every plan from $29.

Best for: Founders and developer-led teams who want daily multi-engine tracking they can query from an API, MCP client or terminal rather than a dashboard.

  • API, MCP and CLI at $29, which most rivals gate to higher tiers
  • Four engines including both Google AI surfaces on the entry plan
Read the full Visiblee review
Passionfruit logo

Passionfruit

#43AI visibility tracker
From $19/mo

$19 entry to page-level citation tracking with AI-channel revenue in the same dashboard and unlimited seats on every plan.

Best for: Solopreneurs, freelance SEOs and small marketing teams who want daily tracking, competitor page citations and AI-channel revenue from GA without paying per seat.

  • Lowest published entry price on this list for daily tracking ($19)
  • Unlimited seats and unlimited competitors on every plan
Read the full Passionfruit review

Articles that mention Gumshoe.AI